Wednesday, September 12, 2018

A critical deconstructed response: Public Toilets are Just Not Good Enough (Katy Rice, The Argus, 21 August)

There has been a higher than usual number of public stories in the past weeks, between the Uritrottoirs in Paris, the launch of the Use Our Loos campaign in the UK and the BBC’s big freedom of information request. This has sparked (as it always does) a number of off-shoots which I have followed with interest. In my news round-up the other day I came across this piece by 52 year old Katie Rice entitled "Public Toilets are Just Not Good Enough." The farther I read the more frustrated I became and felt compelled to respond to it… largely because it embodies everything I feel is backwards about current conversations on public toilet provision and because Katie Rice is not alone in these attitudes. Advance warning, this post is a bit of a personal rant.


Ms. Rice starts out promisingly enough with the tag line: 
“PUBLIC loos are a feminist issue and if they’re not, well, then they should be.”
She lists the standard toilet closures that we have heard so many times, but the piece quickly descends into a Victorian cis-feminist rant, more a self-indulgent lament than a suggestion for any possible progress.  Below are some of the more mis-guided and offensive statements, and my responses.
“Most of us women do not want to urinate in public. […] Some, tanked up on a night out, do it in the street at one in the morning but the rest of us, quite frankly, are a bit more civilized than that.”
The equation of “being able to hold it” with “being civilized” taps right into the stigma and shame we place on bodily functions, from pee to periods to perspiration. “Civilized” people control their bodies and don’t admit to producing odors or substances.
 “We need privacy and that comes in the form of a cubicle because we can’t and don’t use urinals like men, not being in possession of that handy little gadget that allows men to wee standing up.” 
Has she heard of the She-wee? It's literally a handy little gadget which allows women (or people who are not otherwise naturally anatomically equipped) to pee standing up. But that's a minor point... plus they are better suited to hiking than urban adventures. 

Anyway, she goes on: 
“Women have to go into the cubicle, lock the door, partially undress, put loo paper on the seat (not entirely necessary but many of us don’t want to sit on an unclean seat), wee, wipe, dress…”
Aaaagh! What would otherwise be a sensible commentary on the amount of time it takes gets obscured by the perpetuation of toilet-seat germaphobia... the idea that the toilet seat is the grossest thing in the room. I am all for cleanliness and hand-washing and good hygiene, but the list of things that has more germs than a toilet seat could fill volumes. Among the things on that list: the flush button, the door handle, the taps on the sink, and the hand dryer. So unless the toilet seat is literally covered in poo chances are you're not going to come into contact with anything on there that you would touch else-where in the loo. 

But then she enters the most unforgivable territory yet...
“And in the politically correct rush […]”
Uh oh! Red flag for thinly veiled trans/homo/xenophobia coming up. And sure enough she goes on: 
‘[…] to start desegregating public facilities as gender neutral, women’s privacy and safety have not been taken into account. They may well address the concerns of transgender people who face intimidation and harassment in gender segregated facilities […] but they don’t address the safety concerns of women who make up a far greater proportion of the population.”

Okay. Firstly there is, as far as I am aware (and I have looked), no research stating that gender neutral facilities are less safe. In fact, the limited case studies available tend to point to gender neutral facilities having a lower rate of crime than segregated ones and that in fact because they have higher footfall they tend to be safer.

Secondly the argument that cis-women form a “far greater proportion of the population” is or should be irrelevant when weighing the relative safety concerns. Because there most definitely is plenty of documented evidence of trans people facing bathroom discrimination and violence.

This attitude infuriates me, but it is very prevalent. I have had multiple conversations in the past month with women over 50 who are heavily involved in the world of public toilets who, as one put it "Don't see why the majority of us should be inconvenienced because of a small minority." By which she essentially meant she would rather see an already marginalized group of the population be further excluded from society than give up the personal comfort of the gender segregated loos she has known all her life. Only half a century ago in the US people were making the same arguments for racial segregation in toilets...  and their arguments didn't sound all that different from the ones for gender segregation you hear today.
“On a more trivial level, can we trust men to put the seat down afterwards? Can we trust them not to wee all over the seat we women have to sit down on? Yuk. No, thanks.”
This is straying dangerously into the “boys are gross and have cooties” territory, which is really best left behind in kindergarten (or better yet, never introduced into our consciousness in the first place… side tangent: where does this idea come from?) Women wee all over the seat too... especially when they buy into the previously mentioned germophobia and insist on hovering above it.

She finishes: 
"What it all comes back to is a lack of public facilities particularly for women. Women have long complained about this problem but they are not being listened to. I don’t think women are being consulted when new buildings are being designed or about existing public toilets. And I don’t think we are making enough noise about it."
In and of itself I can't fault any of these statements. Yes, there is a lack of facilities. And toilet design in a field historically dominated by heterosexual cis-gended men, and therefore the facilities are designed with their bodies and comfort in mind. So by all means let's make noise about it! But lets do it in a way that looks forward rather than drags us backwards. 

The more I get involved in this world of toilet campaigners the more it strikes me how many conversations about publicly available toilets look backwards instead of forwards. Campaigners arguing for Victorian ideals of a discreet private room, segregated by a comfortable gender binary.

And I'm unsatisfied with my own response because I don't know what all the answers are. But whatever they are I think they have to do with much wider questions than public toilets. Because these places don't exist in isolation. They are a reflection, perhaps even an amplification of, our cultural beliefs about bodies, gender, class, morality and propriety.


21 comments:

  1. Small business owners and entrepreneurs are good at working on their own and thinking outside the box. When things aren't working though, we are not good at something which, if left unchecked, can destroy our business - asking for help. theloanrepublic's long term installment loans

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thankyou for this post, I am a big big fan of this web site would like to proceed updated. why not find out more

    ReplyDelete
  3. Generally I do not read article on blogs, however I wish to say that this write-up very forced me to check out and do so! Your writing taste has been amazed me. Thanks, very great post. facetune app free download

    ReplyDelete
  4. If conceivable, as you clear knowledge, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is damned helpful in return me. free insta likes

    ReplyDelete
  5. Cheap Replica Handbags You guide me by sharing this toolbox i face problem whenever i exploit this promotion reading your blog i am able to easily use. kinemaster pro free download

    ReplyDelete
  6. The article posted was very informative and useful. You people are doing a great job. Keep going. cotomovies free

    ReplyDelete
  7. A blog like yours should be earning much money from adsense.’~::- Dead Target unlimited Money

    ReplyDelete
  8. I like this blog so much, saved to my bookmarks . free patreon

    ReplyDelete
  9. It’s a good shame you don’t contain a give money button! I’d definitely give money for this fantastic webpage! That i suppose for the time being i’ll be satisfied bookmarking together with including an individual’s Feed that will my best Msn balance. That i appearance forward that will recent messages and definitely will share the web site utilizing my best Facebook or twitter team: ) how to download Tweakbox

    ReplyDelete
  10. Can I simply say what a aid to search out somebody who actually is aware of what theyre talking about on the internet. You positively know tips on how to carry an issue to light and make it important. Extra individuals need to read this and perceive this aspect of the story. I cant consider youre no more popular since you undoubtedly have the gift. gifts

    ReplyDelete
  11. The article posted was very informative and useful. You people are doing a great job. Keep going. youtube ++ ios

    ReplyDelete
  12. [...] Jeremy van Horebeek Kent Howerton Neil Hudson Ryan Hughes Georges Jobe Gunnar Johansson [...] video star free effects

    ReplyDelete
  13. You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog. btd battles glitch

    ReplyDelete
  14. Blogs ou should be reading… [...]Here is a Great Blog You Might Find Interesting that we Encourage You[...]…… mortal kombat x souls glitch

    ReplyDelete
  15. of course cruise ships are expensive but of course the trip is very nice“ putlockers

    ReplyDelete
  16. very cool website. I liked the articles and particularly some of the comments posted.. Just stumbled upon your website while doing a Google search. Great info BTW. A shapely Agreeable A shapely. watch hd movie online freemovie7

    ReplyDelete
  17. Immigration… [...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]… how to get free Plague Inc.

    ReplyDelete
  18. hello!,I really like your writing so a lot! percentage we keep up a correspondence extra about your article on AOL? I require an expert on this area to unravel my problem. Maybe that's you! Taking a look ahead to look you. free apple music iphone

    ReplyDelete
  19. When a blind man bears the standard pity those who follow…. Where ignorance is bliss ‘tis folly to be wise…. how to get YouTube++ on iphone

    ReplyDelete
  20. I must admit that your post is really interesting. I have spent a lot of my spare time reading your content. Thank you a lot! how to hack pokemon go

    ReplyDelete
  21. The article posted was very informative and useful. You people are doing a great job. Keep going. coin master cheats

    ReplyDelete